We, Asumi, Kaoru and I, research about Jared Diamond.
1 - Choose one of the Race readings from the ELA reader for this semester.
Diamond
2 - Conduct a Background Wikipedia search for ‘Race’ and check Wikipedia’s rating of the Race article.
WikiProject Sociology (Rated B-class, Top-importance)
WikiProject Anthropology (Rated B-class, Top-importance)
WikiProject Ethnic groups (Rated B-class, Top-importance)
3
- Identify the various different competing positions / views held by
experts in this area and the reasons why they hold these views.
GeographyHuman Society
Biogeography
4 - Conduct a Biography search of the writer of the Race reading you chose.
born on 10 September 1937 in Boston, Massachusetts (Age 75)A.B. degree from Harvard University in 1958
Ph.D. in physiology from Cambridge University in 1961
became professor of Physiology at UCLA Medical school in 1968
professor of UCLA Department of Geography (current)
5 - Try to identify a Bias in that writer’s work
American
Scholar
Jewish
6 - Search for that writer’s articles and books on Amazon.
Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human SocietiesCollapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed
7 - Read the reviews, endorsements and critiques of their work on the Amazon reviews.
Customers review of “Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies Collapse”<endorsements>
As a evolutionary biologist I found Guns, Germs and Steel an excellent read and very thought provoking. As some of the few critics have pointed out, some of his ideas are not new. What is new is that Diamond was able to bring all these ideas together and synthesize them into something quite new and fasinating. The development of human cultures was surely influenced by geography and environment. Diamond has given an incredibly well thought out explanation and theory. The book might seem to some a bit long, perhaps repetitive, but I found it engrossing. It provoked thought (it now makes sense why native Americans were so suseptible to European diseases and not so much the reverse!), overturned my previously held beliefs and meshed human biology and history very well. A must read for biologists, historians, and the general public. And as to the rare reviewer who suggests the book is 'politically correct', from most of their reviews, I have gotten the feeling they hate it because it threatens their closely held world views. All the more reason it deserves the accolades it has received!
<critiques>
Diamond's work should be, but this edition is not acceptable as, a contentious college textbook. There is no excuse for an e-book version lacking printed version content. None. If the e-book version cannot secure the illustration rights, then clearly say so, and drop the price. Otherwise, do not publish. Clearly, anyone can scan the missing content, and make the pirate version worth more then the official.
This e-book version lacks pages, illustrations, and an index. The cover is skewed. There is no notice of the missing content or the flaws, before you buy. DON'T BUY this version. GET A DRM-FREE VERSION, AND STIFF THE PUBLISHER. Buy the author a lunch, via pay-pal or a charity of his choosing.
DO NOT BUY THIS E-BOOK.
<critiques2>
Imagine my surprise when I found out that this book, which I'd been looking forward to reading for so long, isn't a science book at all. It's more of a convoluted political treatise in which the author uses every trick in the book to support his beliefs. He makes completely false statements, omits even the most obvious arguments refuting his position, passes off his poorly formed opinions as fact, and uses some of the most tortured logic I've ever had the misfortune to read.
...
First, the fundamental assumption is flat wrong. Average performances on IQ tests (the best measure at this point) have been rising since the test was first administered. If you don't believe me, look it up--it's called the Flynn Effect. Now, normally, a statement this odd would have sent me scrambling to the footnotes, but there are none. Undoubtedly because they would interfere with Diamond's ability to just make stuff up.
Second, because we have the historical test numbers and we know the dates for the invention and proliferation of television, we can see that there is no correlation with IQ. And finally (okay, I admit to being a bit snarky here) they made a TV show out of this book. Why do I think Diamond would except that particular program from his hypothesis?
We then have his now vaguely infamous and typically unsupported idea that the people of New Guinea are smarter than Europeans because they live in a more violent and dangerous society which selects for intelligence as opposed to European society which tended to select for disease resistance.
While I recognize that this kind of reverse racism is the holy grail of the politically correct "scientist", there's a reason why thinkers much more weighty that Diamond won't touch this subject with a ten foot pole. If we accept Diamond's theory, how long until someone points out that survival in dangerous, violent societies probably selects physically strong, violent people over intelligent ones? Think of it this way: If you had to hire someone to carry your life savings across Somalia on foot, would you choose A: the captain of your high school chess club, or B: a former Navy SEAL in prison for beating a guy to death with a tire iron? So now we're suddenly suggesting that certain races are more prone to violence than others. Oops.
8 - Do a google search of the article plus the word review and see what other results you can find.
http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/256.Jared_Diamond9 - Read the article and put it in context using the results above.